• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
The Mammal Society

The Mammal Society

For Evidence Based Conservation

    • E-mail
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

 

  • Home
  • About
    • What We Do
    • News
    • Blog
    • Meet The Team
    • FAQs
    • Media Information & Press Releases
  • Science
    • Research
      • The Volunteer Mountain Hare Survey
      • Are Britain’s wild animals eating plastics?
      • Harvest Mouse Project
      • PROSIECT ADFER LYGOD DWY YNG NGHYMRU/ WATER VOLE RESEARCH PROJECT.
      • Hedgehog hotspots
      • State of Nature 2019
      • Population Review 2018
      • Red List for Britain’s Mammals
      • Surveys and Projects
    • Publications
      • Mammal Review
      • Mammal Communications
      • Mammal News Magazine
      • Books and equipment
    • Ecostat
    • UK Mammal List
    • Students
  • Training
    • Courses
    • Events
  • Record Mammals
    • How To Record Mammals
    • Mammal Mapper
    • School Resources
    • Discover Mammals
    • County Mammal Recorders
  • Get Involved
    • Surveys and Projects
    • Local Groups
    • Mammal Photographer of the Year (MPOY)
    • The University Mammal Challenge (UMAC)
    • National Mammal Week
  • Support Us
    • Latest Appeal
    • Surveys and Projects
    • Donations
    • Membership
    • Fundraise for us!
    • Leave a Legacy
    • Corporate Supporters
    • Books and equipment
    • Other Ways To Support Us
  • Join Us
  • Donate

Response to DEFRA’s consultation on relaxing the rules for badger culling

10th September 2015

September 2015

The Mammal Society’s response to Defra’s consultation on its plans to update the criteria for badger control licence applications

Defra posed three key questions to stakeholders:

  •  We would be grateful for your views on altering the duration of the culling period. This would involve amending the Guidance to Natural England, which would give greater prominence to Natural England’s discretion whether or not to take action to terminate culling on a case-by-case basis through ongoing assessment of the length of the relevant cull.
  • We would be grateful for your views on reducing the minimum area size in which culling could be licenced to take place to 100km2.
  • We would be grateful for your views on removing the 70% land access requirement from Defra’s Guidance to Natural England, and retaining only a requirement that approximately 90% of land in the cull area should be accessible or within 200m of accessible land

The Mammal Society provided the following response:  

Each of the three proposals outlined by Defra pertain directly to the Defra document “Bovine TB – Key conclusions from the meeting of scientific experts, held at Defra on 4th April 2011”http://www.bovinetb.info/docs/bovinetb-scientificexperts-110404.pdf   This document defines the minimum criteria whereby a badger cull might lead to reduced TB incidence in cattle. These criteria include: culls “covering at least 70% of the land within the culled area”, “a minimum area of 150km2” and that culling is “conducted simultaneously defined as within a 6-week period each year”. 

 

To The Mammal Society’s knowledge, there is no new scientific evidence to suggest that changing these criteria will result in any benefit to cattle health.  Rather, the available evidence suggests that the proposals would reduce the likelihood of a positive outcome for bTB control.  Given this, there appears to be no justification for the proposed softening of licensing criteria.

Consequently, The Mammal Society opposes each of the three proposals. The Mammal Society further considers the lack of independent scrutiny of the current pilot culls to be regrettable, not least because this means there is likely to be a lack of scientific evidence as to the outcomes from the current pilots.  This means they cannot contribute to future decision making on topics such as those contained within this consultation. 

The Mammal Society is also concerned that the culling trials conducted to date have fallen below expected standards of efficacy and humaneness. 

It remains the Mammal Society’s position that, based on the best available scientific evidence, badger culling has no meaningful role to play in the control of bTB in cattle.

Primary Sidebar

Our New Clothing Range

Support our research and campaigns

Shop Today

Our Latest Appeal

Help Our Appeal

What Britain’s wild animals got up to during lockdown

More News

Latest Tweets

Tweets by Mammal_Society

Get Our e-Bulletin

Includes the latest news and updates from Mammal Society!

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
cj-wildlife-logo

 

 

STAY IN THE KNOW
Subscribe to our mailing list and receive regular e-bulletin packed full of mammal news and ways you can get involved with mammal conservation

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Slider

Footer

  • Contact Us
  • Vacancies
  • Position Statements
  • AGM, Reports and Accounts
  • Data Protection
  • Privacy Policy
  • GDPR Information
  • GDPR Opt In

Sponsors

cj-wildlife-logo

 

 

Copyright © 2021 The Mammal Society, Black Horse Cottage, 33 Milton Abbas, Blandford Forum, Dorset DT11 0BL .... Registered Company No. 1455136 Charity No. 278918
Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions
Design by Fingerprint Digital Media